While such a scene would have occurred more than 100 million years ago, a study released this week gives a clearer picture of what went on inside the pterosaur's head. When scientists using skull fossils examined the neuroanatomy responsible for flight control and prey spotting, they found key structures to be specialized and enlarged, a discovery that could revise views of how vision, flight, and the brain itself evolved.
The researchers, led by Lawrence Witmer of Ohio University, took a high-tech look through two skulls of separate species of pterosaurs. Using computerized images derived from X-rays, they peered into the vestibular apparatus, the passageways and chambers responsible for maintaining equilibrium. They also dove "virtually" into the brain cavity to analyze the regions responsible for coordinating wing movements, for scanning the environment, and for "stabilizing gaze," a necessity for airborne predators.
The scientists report their findings in the Oct. 30 issue of the journal Nature. The research team also included Sankar Chatterjee of the Museum of Texas Tech University and Jonathan Franzosa and Timothy Rowe from the University of Texas (UT) at Austin. The trio put the two skulls through the scanner at UT's High-Resolution X-ray Computed Tomography Facility.
The research was supported by the Division of Integrative Biology and Neurosciences of the National Science Foundation (NSF), the independent federal agency that supports fundamental research and education across all fields of science and engineering.
According to William Zamer, who directs NSF's Ecological and Evolutionary Physiology program, "It is a beautifully integrative study: It uses paleontological information, state-of-the-art technology to reconstruct the brain anatomies, and existing knowledge of the working of the semicircular canals to draw fascinating inferences about how these organisms may have performed when they were alive."
Some differences between the two pterosaurs were outwardly apparent.
The skull of Rhamphorhynchus muensteri, a species found in Jurassic formations in Germany, is about five inches long. From its broad back, the skull tapers steadily to a pointed beak.
The skull of Anhanguera santanae, found in the Cretaceous deposits of Brazil, is almost two feet long. Narrower and triangular in cross-section, it tapers toward both the front and the back.
"Anhanguera was quadrupedal and didn't walk solely on its back feet," says Witmer. "It had long forelimbs, though, and so was canted into a more upright position than was the shorter-armed Rhamphorhynchus."
Its head hung at a downward slant, which, according to Witmer, likely enhanced its binocular vision and terrestrial agility.
"The major evidence for the down-turned head," he says, "comes from the orientation of the inner ear canals."
Those, however, remain deep within Anahanguera's rock head, visible only virtually.
To examine the skulls' chambers encased within the mineralized fossils, the researchers used non-invasive X-ray computerized axial tomography - more commonly known as "CAT scans." Custom-built to explore the internal structure of natural - and often fossilized - objects, the scanner at the UT facility has greater resolution and penetrating power than a conventional medical-diagnostic CAT scanner. It feeds its data to DigiMorph, an NSF-funded digital library that develops and makes available 2-D and 3-D structural visualizations of living and extinct animals, mostly vertebrates.
DigiMorph turned the scanners' deep and detailed views into digitized "virtual" endocasts, which revealed more differences between the vestibular networks in the two skulls. For example, the orientation of this "osseous labyrinth" relative to the long axis of the skulls varied. This is particularly noteworthy because of the semicircular canals. These fluid-filled chambers serve as levels to help the brain determine which way is up, arrange an appropriate rate of acceleration, and maintain equilibrium. (All vertebrates have them in their inner ears.)
In Rhamphorhynchus, the orientation of the canals suggests a level-headed approach to flying. In Anhanguera, it suggests a head turned strongly downward both in flight and when on the ground.
Both extinct pterosaurs had about twice the relative amount of labyrinth space than do living birds. (Birds, likewise, have enlarged labyrinths relative to mammals.)
The researchers also found in both animals another greatly enlarged neurological structure critical to flight. Called the flocculus, this lobe of the cerebellum has important connections with the vestibular apparatus, the eye muscles and neck muscles, which work together to stabilize and sharpen an image of prey upon the retina.
The flocculus may also connect to the membrane covering the wing, gathering massive amounts of sensory input on body orientation amidst aerodynamic forces. In both pterosaur subjects, the flocculi occupy about 7.5 percent of total brain mass; in birds, they occupy about 2 percent or less.
According to the Nature report, "Enhancement of such mechanisms seems reasonable in these two visually oriented pterosaurs given their apparent foraging style of aerial fish-eating."
- Available from NSF's Media Section are animation depicting the semi-circular canals and head movements, and an illustration of the pterosaurs' heads and skulls.
For additional photos, illustrations, B-roll, sound bites and animations, see this Ohio University web site: http://www.
Enter the password "flyingreptiles" to access and download.
Principal Investigator: Lawrence Witmer, associate professor of anatomy, Ohio University, (740) 593-9489, firstname.lastname@example.org
Witmer's research lab site: http://www.
Background resources, related news available on the web:
- DigiMorph, NSF's Digital Morphology Library at University of Texas: DigiMorph is a dynamic archive of information on digital morphology and high-resolution X-ray computed tomography of biological specimens. The site offers 2D and 3D visualizations, animations and details on the morphology of many living and extinct animals.
The High-Resolution X-ray Computed Tomography Facility at the University of Texas at Austin (UTCT), an NSF-supported shared multi-user facility: The UTCT offers geologists, biologists, engineers and other researchers access to a nondestructive technique for visualizing features in the interior of opaque solid objects, and for obtaining digital information on their 3-D geometries and properties. Want to scan something there? See the Scanning FAQ.
Dinosaur Discoveries - NSF news releases since 1998: Accounts of news that describe skulls found in Antarctica, models of flight, predation and other dinosaur research topics.
Introduction to the Pterosauria, The Flying Reptiles: At the NSF-supported University of California Museum of Paleontology, this site examines beasts ranging from the size of a sparrow to the size of an airplane. Pterosaurs (Greek for "wing lizards") ruled the skies in the Jurassic and Cretaceous, and included the largest vertebrate ever known to fly.
Receive official National Science Foundation news electronically through the e-mail delivery system, NSFnews. To subscribe, send an e-mail message to email@example.com. In the body of the message, type "subscribe nsfnews" and then type your name. (Ex.: "subscribe nsfnews John Smith")
Useful National Science Foundation Web Sites: