Fast food may be better for your health than steak from a restaurant, according to a just-released study by government scientists who found more cancer-causing compounds in restaurant-prepared meats than in fast food meats.
Suspected cancer-causing compounds known as heterocyclic amines, often formed during cooking, were found in restaurant-prepared meats at levels as much as ten times higher than similar fast food items previously analyzed by the scientists. The study involved beef hamburgers, steaks and pork ribs, purchased from three different national restaurant chains in the Beltsville, Md., area near Washington, D.C.
The study from Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory, the National Cancer Institute and the U.S. Department of Agriculture is reported in the Oct. 31 Web edition of the Journal of Agricultural and Food Chemistry, published by the American Chemical Society, the world's largest scientific society. It is scheduled to appear in the November 16 print edition of the peer-reviewed journal.
Heterocyclic amines are known carcinogens in animals and are believed to contribute to cancer in people.
"Time and temperature" probably account for the difference in fast food and that from other types of restaurants, says Livermore chemist Mark Knize, lead author for the report. Although fast food chains would not divulge their preparation secrets, he said, the researchers believe that fast food cooking times and temperatures are quicker and lower than other restaurants. Previous research has demonstrated that hotter temperatures and longer cooking times are important to the formation of heterocyclic amines.
This is the first time that measurements have been made of heterocyclic amines in meats specifically prepared by restaurant chefs, according to Knize. The "field test" is significant, he says, since it gives clear support to what previously had only been laboratory studies of the formation of the compounds. There are no established rules or guidelines for the acceptable level of heterocyclic amines in food, says Knize.
(The online version of the research paper cited below will be placed on the
American Chemical Society's ASAP (As Soon As Publishable) web site on Oct. 31.
Journalists desiring full access to papers at the ASAP site must submit their
requests in writing to email@example.com in the ACS Office of News & Information.)