Public Release: 

Uncertainty drives the evolution of 'cooperative breeding' in birds

Cell Press

Rather than striking out to start a family of their own, members of some bird species will stick around longer to help a relative raise their young. Now, researchers report evidence that in African starlings such altruistic tendencies are most common among species that live in savannas, where the rainfall in any given year is virtually impossible to predict. The findings appear online August 16 in the journal Current Biology, a publication of Cell Press.

"When the unpredictability of your environment is high, you don't know in advance what conditions you will be facing when the next breeding season rolls around," said Dustin Rubenstein of the University of California, Berkeley and the Cornell Laboratory of Ornithology. "Faced with this uncertainty, it pays, evolutionarily speaking, to live and breed in social groups that will help you weather the bad times and make the most of the good times. Living in cooperative family groups may be like a form of insurance against the unpredictable nature of the environment that allows individuals to maximize their reproductive success over the course of their lifetimes."

Over the past few decades, mounting evidence has shown that many species of cooperatively breeding birds live in semi-arid tropical and sub-tropical environments, particularly in sub-Saharan Africa and Australia. Although that pattern suggested that the environment might explain the behavior, few studies showed a strong relationship between the incidence of cooperative breeding among species and any particular environmental feature, the researchers noted.

In the new study, the researchers examined the pattern of breeding behavior exhibited by 45 species of African starlings in relation to the environments in which they live--including savannas, deserts and tropical forests--while controlling for the evolutionary relationships among them. They also examined the rainfall patterns typical of each of those environments in 47 African countries as far back as 147 years ago.

They found evidence that different starling species have independently evolved the cooperative breeding system upon moving to savannas, where they showed that the amount of year-to-year variation in rainfall is greatest. Rubenstein's group suggested that cooperative breeding is probably advantageous in environments that vary over time because it allows for reproduction in harsh years, as well as sustained breeding during benign years.

Such a strategy might become more widespread in an increasingly uncertain future, the researchers suggested.

"Some researchers have argued that climate change will lead to greater temporal environmental variability," Rubenstein said. "That is, we might expect more extreme weather like severe droughts and devastating floods, and ultimately more variable environments than we see now. If this increase in variability occurs, many species of animals--including humans--will have to adapt to the increasing unpredictability of their environments. By studying how animals have already adapted to temporally variable and unpredictable environments, we can gain insights into how social behavior may change in the wake of climate change."


Dustin R. Rubenstein of University of California, Berkeley (formerly of Cornell Laboratory of Ornithology) and Irby J. Lovette of Cornell Laboratory of Ornithology. This research was supported by grants from the National Science Foundation (NSF) to I.J.L. (DEB- 0515981) and D.R.R. (IBN-0407713), a Chapman Fund grant from the American Museum of Natural History to D.R.R., and a Howard Hughes Medical Institute predoctoral fellowship and a postdoctoral fellowship from the Miller Foundation for Basic Research at the University of California, Berkeley to D.R.R.

Rubenstein et al.: "Temporal Environmental Variability Drives the Evolution of Cooperative Breeding in Birds." Publishing in Current Biology 17, 1-6, August 21, 2007 DOI 10.1016/j.cub.2007.07.032.

Disclaimer: AAAS and EurekAlert! are not responsible for the accuracy of news releases posted to EurekAlert! by contributing institutions or for the use of any information through the EurekAlert system.