Public Release: 

Many low-income women don't want to leave hospital after false-labor diagnosis

Baylor University

More than 40 percent of pregnant low-income women discharged from the hospital after a diagnosis of false or early labor did not want to be sent home, with the most common reasons being that they were in too much pain or lived too far away, according to a study by Baylor University's Louise Herrington School of Nursing (LHSON) and Parkland Health & Hospital System.

Many of the women dissatisfied with being sent home stated that receiving specific written instructions about when to return to the hospital may have made them happier about going home. However, there was evidence that women did receive prenatal instructions about latent labor, according to the study, "Perceptions of Care in Women Sent Home in Latent Labor," published in The American Journal of Maternal/Child Nursing.

Another finding was that comfort is a major aspect of satisfaction with care in latent labor, said study corresponding author Mary Ann Faucher, Ph.D., C.N.M., F.A.C.N.M., associate professor of LHSON.

The study was based on a telephone survey of 100 low-income pregnant women at term presenting for care in latent labor. Faucher noted that no previous studies about the latent labor experience have included disadvantaged populations of women.

Findings were consistent with similar previous studies of more affluent women inside and outside the United States, researchers said.

The study took place in a 968-bed teaching hospital that provides care to approximately 22,000 women a year. Forty-seven percent of the patients are Hispanic and 31 percent are African-American, with a "payer mix" that is 30 percent Medicaid and 26 percent charity care.

In the survey, done from Oct. 12, 2011, until Jan. 2, 2012, women were asked 12 questions. One sample question was whether they were happy being sent home in early labor. If a woman answered "No," a follow-up question asked why they were unhappy and offered a list of reasons. The women could choose more than one answer.

"Eating, drinking and comfort measures were the most common ones women cited that would have made them feel better when in the hospital," the report noted. "A recurring response from women was their desire for very clear and specific written instructions about how to stay comfortable at home and when to return to the hospital."

The study also showed that:

  • 97 percent of the women felt that they received enough attention before being sent home.
  • More than 60 percent reported that they would have felt better if they had been able to eat (68 percent), drink (95 percent) or walk (72 percent).
  • 44 percent would have liked better pain management
  • 36 percent wanted clearer instructions about when to come back.

All the women were asked what would have made them happier about going home and given a list of choices. Answers show that 86 would have liked a follow-up phone call after discharge; 66 wanted written instructions about what to do at home to stay comfortable; 47 women wanted instructions about when to return; and 36 wanted pain medication before being sent home.

Eighty-two women stated that keeping them in the hospital longer would not have improved their perception of care.

There are three stages of labor: beginning labor to full cervical dilation, the pushing phase ending with the delivery of the infant and passage of the placenta. Latent labor is the preparatory phase of the first stage. During latent labor, contractions become more frequent, stronger and regular, with thinning of the cervix. Latent labor may take a few days or be as short as a few hours, Faucher said.

Previous research has established that clinical diagnosis of labor is challenging, with no laboratory tests or procedures that definitively characterize the difference between latent and active labor. Multiple studies have reported that women are conflicted about care in the latent phase of labor. Some women may be more satisfied with care by spending the latent phase of labor at home rather than in the hospital because they are free to move about, eat and drink freely, as well as feeling more in control. Other women feel insecure about staying home and want the care of a health professional. Research also has shown that early labor admission practices can increase the likelihood that care will include more technological interventions, many of which have been reported to decrease maternal satisfaction and increase complications.

Researchers in the Baylor/Parkland study noted that customer satisfaction is an imperative for businesses, including the health care industry.

The study concluded: "Even with the best prenatal instructions, some women are inevitably going to present to the hospital in latent labor. Therefore, hospital best practice should consider policies of ambulation, light nourishment for these women and expanding and diversifying comfort measures while these women are being assessed for admission. The voice of laboring women is calling on care providers to listen to them, inform them about what is going on in their bodies, provide them anticipatory guidance and offer them comfort in all ways possible."


Other researchers included lead author Claire Hosek, DNP, CNM, a graduate of Baylor's nurse-midwifery program, and Janice Lankford, MS, CNM, and James Alexander, MD, former chief of obstetrics at Parkland Hospital in Dallas and former professor at the University of Texas Southwestern Health Science Center.

Disclaimer: AAAS and EurekAlert! are not responsible for the accuracy of news releases posted to EurekAlert! by contributing institutions or for the use of any information through the EurekAlert system.