Countering previously held beliefs, researchers at the University of Texas MD Anderson Cancer Center have discovered that inhibiting the immune receptor protein TLR4 may not be a wise treatment strategy in all cancers. This is because TLR4 can either promote or inhibit breast cancer cell growth depending on mutations in a gene called TP53.
The TLR4 (Toll-like receptor 4) protein, like many other members of important immune system pathways, appears to be a promising target for immune-based therapeutic options and is the focus of many drugs currently in development. As TLR4 was previously thought to be an oncogene, or promoter of tumor growth, these drugs would aim to block its activity and kill cancer cells.
However, new research, published in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, reports that the growth-promoting functions of TLR4 are dependent on the activity of TP53 (Tumor Protein p53), a well-known suppressor of tumor growth.
'This study demonstrated that while TLR4 can function as an oncogene in some breast cancer cells, it acts as a growth suppressor in cases where TP53 is wild-type,' says Powel Brown, M.D., Ph.D., professor and chair, Clinical Cancer Prevention, and senior author. 'Therefore, it may be dangerous to inhibit TLR4 in those cases as you may actually promote cancer growth.'
TLR4 was identified as a frequently mutated gene by MD Anderson's Svasti Haricharan, Ph.D., Clinical Cancer Prevention, in a search for potential drivers of a particular subset of breast cancers with poor outcomes. However, Haricharan, lead author of the study, found that, contrary to expectations for an oncogene, expression of TLR4 was lower in breast cancers compared to normal tissue.
In fact, when comparing survival among breast cancers, Haricharan discovered that better outcomes were associated with a higher expression of TLR4. This is an unexpected result for an oncogene, explains Brown.
Haricharan then examined survival trends associated with TLR4 based on mutations in TP53, which is the most commonly mutated (>50 percent) gene across all cancer types. In cases with TP53 mutations, high levels of TLR4 were associated with low survival rates, as might be expected. Interestingly, in cases with wild-type, or normal, TP53, the trends were exactly the opposite.
The TLR4 protein normally functions in immune cells to activate signaling molecules in response to infection, but it can act in a similar manner to regulate cell growth in cancer cells. By manipulating the activity of TLR4 in breast cancer cell lines, Haricharan found that TLR4 inhibits growth in wild-type TP53 cancer cells through production of a specific signaling compound, interferon gamma. Conversely, TLR4 activity in TP53 mutant cells results in production of different signals that stimulate growth.
Importantly, this study discovered that the link between TP53 and TLR4 is not specific to breast cancer. Malignancies with frequent mutation of TP53, such as ovarian serous, head and neck, and bladder cancers, all appear to retain high TLR4 levels. As cancers with TP53 mutations are much more aggressive and difficult to treat, TLR4 represents a broadly valuable target for these patients.
'This looks like a promising avenue to develop drugs for the worst kinds of cancers,' says Brown. 'However, if we wish to target this immune pathway, we better pay attention to the TP53 status of the tumor.'
A role for TP53 has been connected to the resistance of some cancers to other therapies. Based on these results, the authors suggest the need for further exploration of the balance between the activity of drug targets and that of TP53.
Future work will focus on clarifying which mutations in TP53 are critical for the role of TLR4 in regulating cancer cell growth in order to better understand this complex interaction.
This study was funded by a Cancer Center Support Grant (5 P30 CA016672-38), a Norman Brinker Award for Research Excellence, a John Charles Cain Distinguished Chair Award, the Mariam Rogers Fund for Breast/Women's Cancer Research, The University of Texas MD Anderson Cancer Center Halliburton Fellowship in Cancer Prevention Fund, and the Susan G. Komen Promise Grant (KG081694).