Public Release: 

Genetic mutations differ within a single tumor, study finds

Finding adds complexity to targeted therapies for rectal cancer

University of Michigan Health System


IMAGE: This is Karin Hardiman, M.D., Ph.D. view more

Credit: University of Michigan Health System

ANN ARBOR, Mich. -- When researchers looked at different areas within an individual rectal cancer sample, they found cases in which each area contained different genetic mutations. The findings could have significant implications for treatment recommendations.

Researchers from the University of Michigan Comprehensive Cancer Center used next-generation sequencing techniques to sample the genetic landscape of different geographic areas from tissue samples taken from six patients with rectal cancer.

They found that different regions of a single tumor shared as much as 93 percent of genetic mutations and as little as 67 percent.

"Our paper shows that individual parts of a tumor are different. Some tumors have a lot of variation and some don't. This is the first time anyone has shown this in rectal cancer," says lead study author Karin Hardiman, M.D., Ph.D., assistant professor of surgery at the University of Michigan Medical School.

Genetic variation has been found in other types of cancer, including lung cancer, kidney cancer, and some types of leukemia.

Rectal cancer often returns in the area where it was removed, making treatments such as chemotherapy and radiation crucial in addition to surgery. Chemotherapy choices often are determined from the genetic make-up of the tumor.

"When medical oncologists make decisions about targeted chemotherapy, they typically base that off the results of a single biopsy. If they're testing only one biopsy, it may or may not reflect what's in the rest of the tumor," Hardiman says.

The study authors hypothesize that the differences within a tumor might make the cancer more likely to resist targeted therapies. They are studying patient biopsy samples and mouse models to understand why there is variation within a tumor and why that variation is not present in all tumors.

Mouse models of rectal cancer will also allow the researchers to understand whether certain therapies or combinations of therapies can make a tumor more or less likely to respond.

Results of the study appear in the Nature journal Laboratory Investigation.


Additional authors: Peter J. Ulintz, Rork D. Kuick, Daniel H. Hovelson, Christopher M. Gates, Ashwini Bhasi, Ana Rodrigues Grant, Jianhua Liu, Andi K. Cani, Joel K. Greenson, Scott A. Tomlins, Eric R. Fearon

Funding: National Cancer Institute grants 5P50 CA130810 and 5P30 CA046592, American Surgical Association Foundation Fellowship

Disclosure: None

Reference: Laboratory Investigation, published online Nov. 16, 2015, doi:10.1038/labinvest.2015.131


U-M Cancer AnswerLine, 800-865-1125

U-M Comprehensive Cancer Center, Clinical trials at U-M,

mCancerTalk blog,

For more information, contact:

Nicole Fawcett,

Disclaimer: AAAS and EurekAlert! are not responsible for the accuracy of news releases posted to EurekAlert! by contributing institutions or for the use of any information through the EurekAlert system.