The breast cancer screening tests offered to women may in many cases be unnecessarily painful. New research from Lund University in Sweden shows that strong compression of the breast during mammography screening does not automatically lead to a better basis for diagnosis.
Every year, hundreds of thousands of women aged between 40 and 74 are invited to undergo mammography to detect abnormal changes and tumours in the breast as early as possible. The screening examination is repeated every 1.5 to 2 years.
Despite the extensive screening programme, a large proportion of all breast cancer cases are detected by the patient herself. This could be due to several reasons, but one is that not all women take part in the screening programme. Previous research studies show that the pain of having the breast compressed by the compression plate to obtain a better image is one important reason why some women decline to undergo screening.
Magnus Dustler, MSc in Engineering and a doctoral student at Department of Translational Medicine, Lund University, shows in his research how it is far from certain that strong compression of the breast results in an image which improves the doctors' possibilities for diagnosis. In his thesis, he conducted precise measurements of how pressure is distributed on the breast during mammographic screening:
"Reducing compression by half has little effect on how the pressure is distributed over the central areas of the breast. And they are the ones which are most important for cancer diagnosis."
In his research, he also shows that flexible compression plates, which adapt to the inclination of the breast, distribute the pressure in an advantageous way. The pressure on the usually stiff tissue close to the chest wall is reduced, while the pressure on the central areas of the breast increases.
"Flexible plates therefore enable better image quality without increased compression force. One can also choose to be satisfied with existing image quality and in that case reduce the compression force and the pain", explains Magnus Dustler.
Another problem with current examinations is that many women are recalled unnecessarily. Only an estimated 10 to 20 per cent of the women who are recalled due to suspected changes in the breast have cancer. For the others, the recall generates unnecessary anxiety and also entails major costs for public healthcare.
A possible way of reducing the number of recalls is to add pressure measurement. This means placing pressure sensors on the compression plates before taking the image. As cancer tumours are stiffer than the surrounding breast tissue and fat, it is possible to draw conclusions from the measurement data about potential tumours in the breast.
"The results indicate that it could be possible to set a threshold value: women who exceed this threshold would undergo additional investigation. However, the method is not yet ready for clinical application," says Magnus Dustler.
So far, the collective knowledge about pressure, pain and image quality associated with mammographic screening has only interested researchers on a small scale. And to an even lesser degree, the manufacturers of the equipment used in clinics all over the world. The equipment currently used to compress the breasts is largely equivalent to that used in the infancy of mammographic technology in the 1960s, according to Magnus Dustler.
"But the interest in our findings is increasing and I hope that they will be put to use", he says.
The studies in the doctoral thesis are based on patient data from Skåne University Hospital in Malmö (20-150 participants). Magnus Dustler and his colleagues hope to continue their research in greater depth and to expand on the studies included in the thesis.
Magnus Dustler will publicly defend his thesis "Pressure distribution in mammography" at Lund University on 7 October 2016.
Magnus Dustler, MSc Engineering and doctoral student in Medical Radiation Physics, Department of Translational Medicine at Lund University, Sweden
Tel: +46 (0)768-871189 // +46 (0)40-33 86 56
The studies were funded by the Swedish Breast Cancer Fund, the Malmö General Hospital Foundation for the fight against cancer and General Electrics.
Facts/Breast cancer and mammography screening
Breast cancer is the most common form of cancer among women, affecting over 7 000 women every year in Sweden. Nowadays, the prognosis is good, but treatment is often associated with extensive consequences and suffering for the patient, in the form of medication, radiation and surgical intervention.
Every year, half a million women in Sweden undergo mammography screening to facilitate early detection of tumours in the breast.
Other current research from Lund University among others shows that a new form of 3D mammography, breast tomosynthesis, can increase the possibility of detecting cancer tumours in the breast. In the long term, 3D mammography could complement or even replace current mammographic screening for breast cancer.