image: In one of the largest field experiments ever conducted, an international team measured seed predation at 70 sites across the Americas. view more
Credit: Anna Hargreaves, University of British Columbia, McGill University
One of the largest field experiments ever conducted is providing the best evidence yet in support of a key Darwinian theory--that interactions between species are stronger toward the tropics and at lower elevations.
An international research team used a simple experiment that mimics how plants and animals interact with each other--leaving seeds out for 24 hours to see how many are consumed by animals. Seven thousand seed beds were deployed across a huge geographic area, with 70 sites cutting across 18 mountains from Alaska to the Equator.
"Theory predicts that interactions among species--like predation and competition--will be strongest in the warm, productive, biodiverse ecosystems of the tropics and at low elevations," says lead author Anna Hargreaves, who launched the project while at UBC's Biodiversity Research Centre. She is now a professor at McGill University.
"For example, the spectacular diversity of tropical trees is thought to result partly from stronger interactions between plants and the animals that prey on their seeds, which shapes how and where plants grow and adapt."
But until recently, evidence for this key ecological theory was inconclusive and came from small-scale studies that used different methods.
The new study found seed consumption, or predation, increased by 2.6 per cent for every 10 degrees of latitude toward the Equator and by 0.4 per cent for every 100-metre decline in elevation. In total, seed predation increased 17 per cent between Alaska and Equator and by 17 per cent from 4,000 metres above sea level to sea level.
The researchers used consistent methods from the Arctic to Equator and replicated the 24-hour experiment several times during each latitude's natural seed-producing period.
"These interactions form the basis of how ecosystems function and the direct benefits of those ecosystems to human society," says Santiago David, a PhD student at UBC who ran one of the study sites in Colombia. "Understanding global patterns in key interactions between species, such as seed predation, is essential when we think about managing or restoring the ecosystems, especially in the face of climate change."
Predation driven by insects, other invertebrates
By protecting some seeds from mammals, the researchers showed that the study's large-scale patterns are being driven by the smallest seed predators: insects and other invertebrates.
The only other standardized experiment of comparable scale used clay model caterpillars and found that attack rates on the model caterpillars increased toward low latitudes--an interaction also driven largely by invertebrates.
"Taken together, these experiments suggest that invertebrates play an outsized role in the community dynamics and evolution of tropical and lowland ecosystems," says Hargreaves. "And yet we know relatively little about invertebrates, for example, how climate change is affecting their populations."
The researchers are now combining fake caterpillars with the seeds to determine if the patterns they found with one form of predation hold true with another.
The study, "Seed predation increases from the Arctic to the Equator and from high to low elevations," involved researchers from 13 institutions across the Americas, was published today in Science Advances.
https://doi.org/10.1126/sciadv.aau4403
###
Multimedia and captions
Photos and video of insects and animals eating seeds at study depots, and wide shots of regions involved in study are available at:
https://www.dropbox.com/sh/rc24l5j7asyz8gw/AAD3K-2etMY1AOoIz99ryModa?dl=0
Seed depot sites
6 site highmid latitude (BC Canada) low elev A Hargreaves.JPG
In one of the largest field experiments ever conducted, an international team measured seed predation at 70 sites across the Americas. Low elevation, mid-latitude site in British Columbia, Canada (Anna Hargreaves, University of British Columbia, McGill University).
7 site highmid latitude with depot (BC Canada) A Hargreaves.JPG
In one of the largest field experiments ever conducted, an international team measured seed predation at 70 sites across the Americas. Mid-elevation, mid-latitude site with feeding depot in the foreground, British Columbia, Canada (Anna Hargreaves, University of British Columbia, McGill University).
8 site low latitude (CostaRica) 700m elev H Slinn.JPG
In one of the largest field experiments ever conducted, an international team measured seed predation at 70 sites across the Americas. Tropical site in Costa Rica (Heather Slinn, University of Nevada Reno).
9 site low latitude (Colombia) 2700m elev S David.JPG
In one of the largest field experiments ever conducted, an international team measured seed predation at 70 sites across the Americas. High elevation tropical site in Colombia (Santiago David, University of British Columbia).
10 seed depot with cage (southern BC Canada) A Hargreaves.JPG
In one of the largest field experiments ever conducted, an international team measured seed predation at 70 sites across the Americas. A caged seed depots measures seed predation by invertebrates in southern British Columbia, Canada (Anna Hargreaves, University of British Columbia, McGill University).
Insects, small mammals eating seed at depots
11 seed predator ants (Baja Mexico) S Vanderplank.JPG
In one of the largest field experiments ever conducted, an international team measured seed predation at 70 sites across the Americas. Ants preying on seeds in Baja, Mexico (Sula Vanderplank, Botanical Research Institute of Texas).
12 seed predator ants (Cali Colombia) 1800m S David.JPG
In one of the largest field experiments ever conducted, an international team measured seed predation at 70 sites across the Americas. An ant swarm preying on seeds near Cali, Colombia (Santiago David, University of British Columbia).
13 seed predator banana slug (southern BC Canad...A Hargreaves.jpg
In one of the largest field experiments ever conducted, an international team measured seed predation at 70 sites across the Americas. A banana slug eating seeds, southern BC Canada (Anna Hargreaves, University of British Columbia, McGill University).
14 seed predator arctic ground squirrel (Yukon) S AngersBlondin.jpg
In one of the largest field experiments ever conducted, an international team measured seed predation at 70 sites across the Americas. Arctic ground squirrels were the major seed eaters in the Yukon (Sandra Angers-Blondin, University of Edinburgh).
Videos of animals eating experimental seeds
vid small mammal eating seeds Colombia2 S David.MP4
vida small mammal 2018 2678m Jardin Colombia.MP4
vidb small mammal 2018 2678m Jardin Colombia.MP4
vidc small mammal 2018 2678m Jardin Colombia.MP4
Small mammal eating seeds from a study depot in Colombia (Santiago David, University of British Columbia).
vid banana slug eating seeds A Hargreaves.MOV
Captive banana slug eats experimental seeds in an early pilot study, southern BC (Anna Hargreaves, University of British Columbia, McGill University).
Wide shots of regions involved in study
1 site high latitude (Alaska) high elev J Brodie.JPG
In one of the largest field experiments ever conducted, an international team measured seed predation at 70 sites across the Americas. A high latitude, high elevation site in Alaska (Jedediah Brodie, University of Montana).
2 site high latitude (Yukon) low elev A Hargreaves.JPG
3 site high latitude (Yukon) low elev A Hargreaves.JPG
4 site high latitude (Yukon) low elev A Hargreaves.JPG
In one of the largest field experiments ever conducted, an international team measured seed predation at 70 sites across the Americas. High latitude low elevation site in the Yukon (Anna Hargreaves, University of British Columbia, McGill University).
4b site high latitude (Yukon) S Angers-Blondin.jpg
In one of the largest field experiments ever conducted, an international team measured seed predation at 70 sites across the Americas. Hill in background shows a high latitude transect in the Yukon (Sandra Angers-Blondin, University of Edinburgh).
5 site high latitude (Yukon) mountains A Hargreaves.JPG
In one of the largest field experiments ever conducted, an international team measured seed predation at 70 sites across the Americas. High latitude study area in the Yukon (Anna Hargreaves, University of British Columbia, McGill University).
5b site high latitude (Yukon) high elev S Angers-Blondin big.jpg
In one of the largest field experiments ever conducted, an international team measured seed predation at 70 sites across the Americas. High latitude, high elevation site in the Yukon (Sandra Angers-Blondin, University of Edinburgh).
Journal
Science Advances