A research team consisting of Ryota Kondo (Ph.D. candidate), Yamato Tani (Graduate student), and Professor Michiteru Kitazaki from Toyohashi University of Technology; Associate Professor Maki Sugimoto from Keio University; and Professor Masahiko Inami from The University of Tokyo investigated the difference between the sense of ownership of the whole body and the sense of ownership of body parts using scrambled body stimulation. Only the observer's hands and feet were presented, and their spatial arrangement was randomized. It was found that observing the scrambled body stimulus while moving the whole body produces a sense of possession of the body part with respect to the hands and feet, but cannot sense possession of the whole body. This result suggests that spatial arrangement is important for the illusion of whole-body ownership. In addition, a person's bodily self-consciousness may be affected by the spatial arrangement of one's own body. The results of this study were published in the open access journal Scientific Reports in 24th March 2020.
Whole body ownership is an important phenomenon to examine bodily self-consciousness. However, differences between ownership in body parts and ownership in the whole body are not completely understood as there is no effective method to separate these senses of ownership.
Therefore, the research team aimed to develop a method to separate the ownership of body parts from the ownership of whole body. Based on their previous study (Kondo et al., Scientific Reports, 2018) on transparent body stimulation, a scrambled body stimulation that randomly rearranges the positions of hands and feet was conducted. Then, in order to compare it with the stimulus of the same arrangement as the normal body, synchronization with the physical movement was controlled.
In Experiment 1, 16 volunteers observed limb-only stimuli from a third-person perspective (2 m behind the stimuli) on a head-mounted display. As a result, when vision and physical movement were synchronized, scrambled body stimulation produced only body part ownership (It felt as if the virtual limbs were of their body), whereas normal placement body stimulation produced both body part ownership and whole body ownership (it felt as if the space between the limbs was their body). Similar results were obtained in Experiment 2, in which 16 participants observed the stimulus from a first-person perspective. Thus, humans can have ownership of body parts even if the body parts are scrambled, but cannot have the whole-body ownership. However, there was no significant difference in any of the skin conductance response measurement experiments for threat stimuli in Experiment 3, conducted on 20 participants.
These results suggest that a spatial placement is necessary for whole-body ownership, but not necessarily for body-part ownership. Therefore, a person's bodily self-consciousness might be restricted by the spatial arrangement of normal body parts. However, the limitation of this study was that there was no difference in skin conductance (physiological) response to a threat stimulus.
Scrambled body stimulation provides a method to systematically examine the sense of ownership of the whole body and body parts. Moreover, it helps explore the limitations of the illusion of how much we can change our body scheme while retaining whole-body ownership.
Kondo, R., Tani, Y., Sugimoto, M., Inami, M., and Kitazaki, M. (2020). Scrambled body differentiates body part ownership from the full body illusion. Scientific Reports, 10, DOI: 10.1038/s41598-020-62121-9
Funding: This research was supported by JST ERATO Grant Number JPMJER1701 (Inami JIZAI Body Project), and JSPS KAKENHI Grant Number P19J12660.
Toyohashi University of Technology
1-1 Hibarigaoka, Tempaku
Toyohashi, Aichi Prefecture, 441-8580, JAPAN
Inquiries: Committee for Public Relations
Toyohashi University of Technology was founded in 1976 as a National University of Japan, and is a leading research institute in the fields of mechanical engineering, advanced electronics, information sciences, life sciences, and architecture.