Article Highlight | 16-Nov-2026

Why some shoppers skip coupons—even when they offer a deal

Indiana University

BLOOMINGTON, Ind. — Coupons promise savings, but not every shopper sees them as clear-cut bargains. For some consumers, such discounts may lead them to ask where’s the catch?

New research published in the Journal of Marketing found that people who endorse inequality and unequal distribution of resources – known as “power distance belief” – were less likely to use coupons, in part because they are more skeptical of businesses’ motives.

Very little research has examined how cultural values shape consumers’ responsiveness to coupons.

Power distance belief describes how much a person accepts unequal distributions of power in society. Shoppers with higher levels of this belief may see a coupon as a business tactic rather than a genuine offer of value. That skepticism can make them less inclined to redeem it, said Ashok Lalwani, professor of marketing at the Indiana University Kelley School of Business.

The underlining issue is about trust, said Lalwani, co-author of the paper, “Power Distance Belief Affects Coupon Use.” When consumers suspect that a business has a self-serving reason for offering a discount, then a coupon feels less like real savings.

For example, instead of flocking to a perceived deal, these consumers may believe the company raised the price before issuing the coupon, or they may raise questions about if something is wrong with the product because of the discount.

The implication for companies of the research is significant, given the millions spent annually to provide coupons – in printed or electronic form – as a form of marketing. Low redemption rates – estimated by some to be less than 1% — cause inefficiencies as coupons are sent to a large segment of the population with only a small fraction responding.

“Marketers are continuously trying to identify consumer segments that are more or less likely to respond to couponing efforts, as this knowledge enables them to fine-tune the segments to whom coupons are directed,” Lalwani said. “There are printing costs; there are distribution costs and then there’s the cost at the point of purchase. In our paper, we help marketers better identify segments of consumers who are more or less likely to use coupons.”

The paper’s findings point to ways businesses might make coupon offers more appealing: explain them clearly, address doubts about the company’s motives, and consider price-matching guarantees.

The researchers also suggest that marketers consider cultural differences in coupon campaigns and that situational cues may influence how people respond. Lalwani said that businesses could encourage coupon use by making their motives seem more trustworthy, or by using messages and situations that emphasize customers’ ability to compare prices and make their own choices.

Lalwani said this research is among the first to measure Power Distance Belief scores at the state level within the United States and demonstrates that political orientation can be used as a proxy for PDB in predicting coupon use.

“Southern states … tend to be, have a very high Power Distance Belief. On the other hand, New York and California generally are low in Power Distance Belief – they advocate egalitarianism a lot more,” he said. “A marketer who relies on coupons can expect that the couponing strategy will be more successful in states, countries, and even neighborhoods where people’s power distance is low.”

He and his colleagues said the findings indicate that trust can be gained through policies such as a price-matching guarantee. It signals that the business will honor a fair price even if a customer finds a lower one elsewhere, and the authors reported that this can remove the gap in coupon use.

The findings came from a set of eight studies, including two field studies, a dataset of actual shopping activity, and experiments, with additional studies in the online appendix.

Other authors of the paper are Minkyung Koo, associate professor of marketing at the University of New Mexico, and Sijie Sun, assistant professor of marketing at the University of Manitoba.

Disclaimer: AAAS and EurekAlert! are not responsible for the accuracy of news releases posted to EurekAlert! by contributing institutions or for the use of any information through the EurekAlert system.