image: City crows and country crows react to objects and people differently based on their experiences, according to a new study by biologists at Binghamton University, State University of New York.
view more
Credit: “crow” by grendelkhan, CC BY-SA 2.0
A country crow hesitates upon seeing a take-out food box. A city crow pauses the first time they saw an ear of corn. Both are taken aback when they find a strange wooden object next to the expected peanuts.
That hesitation when encountering new things is known as neophobia, and all animals experience it, including humans, explained Binghamton University, State University of New York biologist Dave J. Colucci, PhD ’25, the lead author of a new study published in the journal Behavioral Ecology that examined how experience shapes the behavior of urban and rural crows.
While known for their curiosity and smarts, corvid species worldwide also exhibit considerable neophobia. Of course, the birds have an advantage: their ability to fly means that they can take a discreet position and observe phenomena before taking action, which may also contribute to their famed problem-solving skills, according to co-author and Binghamton University Associate Professor Emerita of Biological Sciences Anne Clark.
“They’re both wary of new things and somehow very curious. They overcome that fear sometimes and manage to take advantage of new opportunities,” Colucci explained.
Rocks, corn, and other new objects
The research project assessed both neophobia and crows’ reaction to the human gaze in 10 families of urban crows in the Ithaca, N.Y., area and another 10 families in nearby rural Dryden. Both were fed their preferred food: peanuts in the shell.
Once habituated to the interaction, the researchers began presenting the peanuts alongside an object: a rock, an ear of corn, a takeout food box, and a wooden lamp base. Familiar objects — a rock for both groups, corn for the rural crows, and the paper takeout box for the urban ones — evoked little hesitation. Unfamiliar objects — the takeout box for rural crows, corn for urban crows, and the lamp for both — resulted in increased wariness.
“What we wanted to show was that aversion would decrease with the amount of experience that we expected our crow to have had with these objects,” Colucci explained.
Fun fact: Crows who establish territories near an Arby’s or a McDonald’s learn to recognize the takeout boxes from that business, Clark pointed out. In this case, the researchers’ takeout box was generic and brand-neutral.
It turns out that crows in urban environments exhibited more neophobia than those who lived in the countryside, the researchers found. This was a somewhat surprising result, given that many studies have shown that urban birds were less neophobic than rural counterparts. But such studies have not controlled for experience with the novel object. In some ways, it resembles the behavior of human city-dwellers; urban humans, too, are peripherally on the lookout for strange phenomena and react accordingly. In this study, corn and lamps were really strange from the point of view of an urban crow.
“These are social animals; they’re with a group, and they watch each other,” Clark said of urban crows. “In an area that has a lot of new opportunities, there are also new threats, and it’s good to maintain some level of uncertainty about how safe things are.”
The human gaze
While rural crows may be less fearful when presented with novel objects, they were much more fearful of humans overall, research showed.
Urban crows pay attention to the direction of the human gaze. If the human isn’t looking at them directly, they’re less likely to fly away. Rural crows, by contrast, were more likely to fly away at a greater distance than urban crows, no matter what direction the approaching human was looking.
The reason may be simple: Crows, considered a nuisance species, are more likely to be shot in rural areas.
“You can think of it as a blunt, anti-predator strategy in rural areas. Don’t take any chances, don’t stop to assess; let’s just be safe,” Clark said. “Whereas in urban areas, if you were fleeing at every human, you’d never spend any time on the ground. More evidence that urban crows are on the lookout for useful information about threats, including the behavior of individual humans!”
Both experiments demonstrate the importance of animals’ lived experience in responding to novel phenomena in their environment — whether a takeout box or an approaching human. They also show how animals can adapt to increased urbanization without changing their fundamental attributes and overall survival strategies.
“It fits into a larger picture of how organisms adapt to a changing world,” Clark said.
Journal
Behavioral Ecology
Method of Research
Experimental study
Subject of Research
Animals
Article Title
Experience affects novel object aversion and the use of human cues in rural and urban American crows
Article Publication Date
22-Oct-2026