News Release

The avian champions of long-distance migration keep surprising scientists

Peer-Reviewed Publication

Florida Museum of Natural History

Image 1

image: 

Shorebirds in the sandpiper family are the uncontested champions of long-distance migration, often traveling thousands of miles without stopping. A new study uses ancient and modern DNA to determine where all that long-distance travel took them over the last 30 million years. 

view more 

Credit: Illustration by Archibald Thorburn, 1916, CC0

Key points

  • Shorebirds in the sandpiper family are the uncontested champions of long-distance migration, often traveling thousands of miles without stopping.
  • Snipes and woodcocks are two of the only groups in this family that often seem to have foregone these trans-oceanic journeys and permanently settled down on islands.
  • In a new study, scientists at the Florida Museum of Natural History, Virginia Tech and the Field Museum of Natural History sequenced modern and ancient DNA, showing that this penchant for aborted migrations has helped shape the evolutionary history of woodcocks and snipes and resulted in complex patterns that have fooled experts on more than one occasion.
  • The study also reveals an unexpectedly close relationship between the snipes of South America and those of the southwest Pacific islands.

Gainesville, Fla. --- “The whole story began with an extinct bird from Hispaniola,” said Min Zhao, a former postdoctoral associate at the Florida Museum of Natural History (now a postdoctoral researcher at Uppsala University).

The bird in question was identified as a woodcock in 2015 based on several fossils excavated by Florida Museum researchers in 1984 from a Haitian cave on the island of Hispaniola.

Woodcocks are medium-sized birds with long, slightly curved beaks that appear to protrude from their necks and a bouncy back-and-forth gait that looks like a funky, two-step dance number. Scientists think this comic method of locomotion may mimic the vibrations made by falling rain, which is a cue for earthworms to move upward before the soil becomes waterlogged and they drown. Instead, vertically migrating earthworms encounter the slender bill of the woodcock.

In a new study published in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, Florida Museum researchers sequenced ancient DNA from the fossil specimens and show that what was thought to be a woodcock is actually a snipe.

That in itself isn’t very surprising. Woodcocks and snipes are each other’s closest relatives, having diverged from a common ancestor about 25 million years ago. To the untrained eye, they can look nearly identical. The misidentified snipe also had short wings and big legs — two common traits in island birds — compared to what scientists now know are its closest relatives.

But the combined efforts of the research group reveal a broader story about migration and evolution in a group of birds famous for flying nonstop from the high latitudes of one hemisphere to those of the other. 

“Shorebirds are the ultimate long-distance migrants,” said study co-author David Steadman, the emeritus curator of ornithology at the Florida. “It’s common for shorebirds to nest up in the Arctic tundra and winter in South America. There was recently a bristle-thighed curlew that was radio-tagged and showed up in New Zealand after flying 10,000 km without stopping.”

Similar to curlews, woodcocks and snipes also travel long distances, but unlike curlews and most other shorebirds, they also include several species whose ancestors opted out of migration and permanently settled down on islands. There are eight living species of woodcock, for example, and six of them are endemic to islands.

“Some people argue that it’s their migratory propensity that has led them to colonize islands. But there are a lot of migrant shorebirds that travel long distances. Woodcocks and snipes are the only ones setting up resident populations on islands. They’ve radiated on islands in the Caribbean, Japan, Indonesia, the western Pacific, and the greater New Zealand area,” Steadman said.

Intrigued by the results of the ancient DNA analysis, Steadman and his colleagues wanted to see if they could learn more about how woodcocks and snipes evolved and radiated around the world over the last quarter-million years.  

The study’s co-authors collected small tissue samples from specimens in museums across the country for all but one of the 29 extant woodcock and snipe species. Jessica Oswald, a postdoctoral researcher then working at the Florida Museum of Natural History, extracted and sequenced DNA from these samples and — with help from co-author Brian Stucky — managed to do so for the Hispaniolan fossils as well. She also included DNA from one additional extinct species, the South Island snipe, which disappeared in 1964 following the human-mediated introduction of black rats to South and Stewart Islands in New Zealand.

They added the age of shorebird fossils to their DNA data and analyzed both together to produce a time-calibrated phylogeny, or what is essentially the species-level equivalent of a family tree with dates added to it.

Several of the authors have conducted similar studies in the past. Co-author Jessica Oswald extracted ancient DNA from numerous fossil specimens while working as a postdoctoral researcher at the Florida Museum.

Over the last several years, she and her colleagues have shown that large rodents called hutias were intentionally transported to the Bahamas by humans more than 1,000 years ago to be a source of food; that an old folktale about a shipwrecked Spanish galleon and its equine passengers said to have been marooned on an island off the coast of Virginia is likely more fact than fiction; that Haitian cave rails — an extinct group of birds that once inhabited parts of the Caribbean — were most closely related to adzebills in New Zealand and flufftails in Africa and the South Pacific, not to species of rail living on the American continents; that Caribbean parrots thought to be naturally endemic to certain islands are actually the last remnants of species that were once more broadly distributed before the arrival of humans to the area; and that an endangered dove endemic to Cuba is more genetically distinct than the now-extinct dodo — also in the dove family — and is likewise in danger of dying out.

The results of the current study have a similar flavor to the revelation that Caribbean cave rails originally hailed from halfway around the world.

The first big mix-up occurred around 20 million years ago, when one or a few adventurous woodcocks made their way from Eurasia — where its relatives originated — to North America. At around a similar time, snipes in Eurasia dispersed to South America, where they evolved into several species. This includes the extinct Caribbean snipe whose ambiguous fossils would later vex ornithologists.

The woodcock’s journey to North America isn’t all that unusual. The close proximity of modern-day Russia and Alaska would have provided ample opportunity for dispersal if it crossed from Asia, and both Iceland and Greenland would have made similarly suitable stopovers if it crossed from Europe.

But the snipe’s journey from Eurasia to South America is out of the ordinary, given that it deviated from the usual North/South migration pattern by veering west across the width of an entire ocean.

Yet, about seven million years later, the South American snipes seem to have repeated the same feat on an even grander scale by flying to the Southwest Pacific Islands, where they again diversified into several species.

This result was completely unexpected. The South Pacific island austral snipes — also known as the New Zealand snipes or tutukiwi in Māori — look remarkably different (to an ornithologist) from their relatives in South America and Eurasia, so much so that scientists separated them into their own genus called Coenocorypha. But the study again showed that looks can be deceiving, because the austral snipes are deeply embedded in a lineage of mostly South American snipes.

If this were a genealogical tree, the austral snipes would be the rebellious sibling that ran away from home and changed its name and appearance but — despite its best efforts — remained a part of the family.

In the future, scientists will either have to get rid of the genus Coenocorypha and lump all the species previously referred to by that name as Gallinago, or they can keep Coenocorypha and establish two additional genera for the cousins that live in South America. However, the authors of the present study did not propose any taxonomic changes.

The subtleties of nomenclature aside, the authors remain perplexed by the geographic split. Rather than an unusual long-distance dispersal from one distant landmass to another in the same hemisphere, Oswald said there’s another possibility that would explain the pattern.

“One hypothesis is that perhaps there were many closely related species on islands across the Pacific that are now extinct, just like what has been found in rails” she said.

This would be like leaving a trail of breadcrumbs on the islands that led them to New Zealand and nearby islands — the breadcrumbs in this case being various endemic snipe species — only for those breadcrumbs to be consumed by humans. Literally.

“People will eat anything,” Oswald said. “You get one group of explorers or whalers that stop at one of these islands, and they could wipe out the entire bird community in a weekend because they were hungry.”

This isn’t an exaggeration. In an article he published in The New Yorker in 1976, the naturalist Peter Matthiessen described 19th-century hunts in which gunners would shoot down thousands of birds in a single day.

The birds, he wrote, “…were unsuspicious to a fault. The Eskimo curlew [a species of shorebird] would circle back over the guns, calling out for its fallen companions — a habit it shared with the dunlin, dowitcher, and many others.”

The Eskimo curlew is now extinct largely because of unrestrained hunting.

He went on to write that some birds in this group were overconfident in the ability of their camouflaged plumage to keep them hidden.

“The thick-knees [in the Burhinidae family of shorebirds] dependence on disruptive coloration is often so exaggerated that it will permit itself to be picked up from the stony ground on which it crouches. It seems convinced, despite the bad turn that events have taken, that it is nowhere to be seen.”

This naivety is often even more pronounced in island birds who have never before encountered humans and therefore don’t have the wherewithal to be afraid.

If humans don’t directly finish off endemic species after arriving on an island, the rats, cats and other invasive species they bring with them can do so in short order, as seems to have been the case with the Caribbean snipe, which disappeared sometime after the 17th century. The same fate seems to have befallen six other extinct species in the provisionally named genus Coenocorypha.

Additional coauthors of the study are João Capurucho and John Bates of the Field Museum of Natural History; Brian Stucky of the U.S. Department of Agriculture; Michelle LeFebvre and Robert Guralnick of the Florida Museum of Natural History; and Julie Allen of Virginia Tech.


Disclaimer: AAAS and EurekAlert! are not responsible for the accuracy of news releases posted to EurekAlert! by contributing institutions or for the use of any information through the EurekAlert system.