image: A community park in an informal settlement in Nairobi, Kenya, restoring highly transformed and degraded urban spaces to create green and recreational areas through planting vegetation and creatively reusing waste materials. Credit: Edwin Kirima, SDI-Kenya (KYCTV)
Credit: Edwin Kirima, SDI-Kenya (KYCTV)
New research from UCT says nature-based solutions for climate adaptation must move beyond participation to power-sharing partnerships that recognise lived experiences and relationships with nature.
As climate change intensifies flood risks in cities across Africa, nature-based solutions (NbS) like urban wetlands, community food gardens, and sustainable urban drainage systems are increasingly promoted as climate adaptation for urban informal settlements.
However, a bold new comment published in Nature Communications warns that despite successful community-led interventions, many funded nature-based solutions rarely reach or benefit informal settlements because they bypass lived experiences and deep-seated power imbalances.
Authored by Dr Petra Holden and Professor Gina Ziervogel from the African Climate & Development Initiative (ACDI) at the University of Cape Town (UCT), the paper issues an urgent call to municipal planners, national policymakers, and international climate funders across the Global South to move past participatory consultation toward genuine power-sharing partnerships.
“Many nature-based solutions projects framed as co-design initiatives begin with predetermined ideas and priorities that originate outside informal settlements, rather than from those who live within them,” says Holden, who is also lab lead at the ACDI’s People in Nature and Climate (PiNC) Lab.
Drawing on their work with the Tuwe Pamoja project, which was carried out across four African cities including Cape Town, the authors explore challenges and opportunities for nature-based solutions to support just climate adaptation. They share insights from the Khayelitsha informal settlement, to illustrate the complex trade-offs faced by settlement residents. Many there live along vulnerable river and wetland edges, accepting severe flood risks simply to secure a place to live.
The authors point out a persistent gap between how external decision-makers see urban problems and potential NbS initiatives - and how settlement residents actually relate to and experience them. Experts themselves might be divided, with for example, an ecologist wanting to restore a wetland to its fully natural historical state, while a city engineer might want to build concrete storm drains.
Meanwhile, residents might also be split, with some urgently seeking flood protection, and others wanting space for vegetable gardens or places for kids to play. At the same time, city officials might debate whether to build concrete or nature-based flood protection structures to protect settlements or neighbouring suburbs, which could mean bulldozing homes and relocating families.
Without inclusive deliberation on competing claims, decisions on nature-based solutions may leave trade-offs invisible, and enable external technocratic priorities to dominate.
"Unless we confront underlying power imbalances and bring in local voices and priorities, technocratic perspectives will continue to shape climate adaptation at the direct expense of vulnerable communities," says Ziervogel, who is Director of the ACDI at UCT.
The researchers outline three pathways to nurture nature-based solutions processes for just climate adaptation. First, they highlight distributive justice, and the need to acknowledge competing claims over land and water to deliberate fairly around potential solutions.
They also call for establishing power-sensitive partnerships, which means shifting away from short-term externally-led consultations toward long-term trust-building and shared decision-making. This, they urge, must be backed by funding and incentive models that explicitly motivate government and provide resources for local leaders and community facilitators to deliberate trade-offs, mediate conflict, and mobilise meaningful collaboration.
Finally, the authors call for embracing care-full pluralism, which demands that decision-makers recognise multiple ways of knowing. This means bridging scientific approaches with the lived experiences, values, and cultural relationships with nature held by diverse groups of experts, including local residents.
"Achieving resilience means recognising that nature is not just a technical fix or environmental privilege - it is an integral part of community identity, survival, and belonging,” Holden says.
Journal
Nature Communications
Method of Research
Commentary/editorial
Subject of Research
People
Article Title
Power-sensitive partnerships for just nature-based solutions in urban informal settlements
Article Publication Date
13-Nov-2026