News Release

In a new book titled, Biblical Forgery and Academic Authentication: Persisting Patterns of Guile and Gullibility, BU researcher examines the role scholars have played in legitimizing biblical forgeries

Book Announcement

Boston University

Cover of book by Jonathan Klawans

image: 

A new book, Biblical Forgery and Academic Authentication: Persisting Patterns of Guile and Gullibility, examines the role scholars have played in legitimizing biblical forgeries. 

view more 

Credit: Courtesy of Oxford University Press, 2026

How do experts distinguish authentic ancient artifacts from sophisticated fakes? And what happens when scholars responsible for verifying those artifacts get it wrong?

In 2016, the Museum of the Bible in Washington, DC, displayed a collection of 13 tiny fragments believed to be part of the Dead Sea Scrolls—ancient Jewish manuscripts dating back more than 2,000 years. The fragments were later determined to be forgeries. But how did they fool the experts in the first place?

Academic forgeries have been taking place for centuries—from Cyrus Gordon’s 1970s “authentications” of ancient Hebrew inscriptions discovered in America to suspicious Deuteronomy manuscripts offered for sale by Moses Wilhelm Shapira in 1883.

In his new book, Biblical Forgery and Academic Authentication: Persisting Patterns of Guile and Gullibility (Oxford University Press, 2026), Jonathan Klawans, professor of religion and Jewish studies and chair of the Department of Religion at Boston University, examines the role scholars have played in legitimizing biblical forgeries. Drawing on cases spanning more than a century, Klawans explores why even highly trained experts can be deceived, how questionable artifacts gain academic credibility, and what these episodes reveal about the ethics and practices of biblical scholarship.

In the Q&A below, Klawans describes what makes a forgery convincing, why scholars sometimes overlook warning signs, and what the history of biblical forgery can teach us about the pursuit of truth.

Q: Your book explores cases in which respected scholars authenticated artifacts that turned out to be forgeries. How does this happen? Why are even experienced scholars susceptible to being fooled?

Scholars fall for finds that support their views, even while being skeptical of those that don’t. Purported Hebrew inscriptions ostensibly discovered here in America appealed to a scholar who wanted to believe that the Americas were visited by ancient Israelites. A gospel fragment ostensibly alluding to Jesus having a wife appealed to a scholar interested in evidence supporting the participation of women in early Christian worship and leadership.

But there’s another factor: scholars of religion in general—and biblical studies in particular—often display ignorance of the history of forgery. Scholars say things like “this couldn’t be forged” or “no one would forge this”—but these guesses are based on hopes, not established knowledge of the talents and motivations of forgers.

And so a third factor comes in too: we scholars, not without reason, tend to think we are very smart. But who said forgers can’t be just as smart, or even smarter?

When scholars, ignorant of forgery, downplay the capacities of forgers—or assume that forgers forge only because of money—they leave themselves open to the possibility of being fooled by highly motivated—and highly skilled—forgers.

Q: What makes biblical artifacts particularly attractive targets for forgery?

First, there is a great thirst for biblical knowledge, and the possibility of finding the next great thing is tempting. Second, there is a market for biblical objects: collectors, both Jewish and Christian, will purchase objects that are forwarded for sale, whether in the licensed antiquities shops of Israel and the Palestinian territories, or in black markets operating throughout the Middle East. Third, there is a tolerance among some scholars and even museums for these objects—a sense that the potential importance of what can be learned outweighs the moral concerns of illicit purchases.

And here’s the problem: if we open our eyes, minds—and pockets—to objects coming from the markets—as opposed to proper archaeological discoveries—the possibility that forgers will provide what the buyers want is, well, perhaps inevitable.

Q: Of all the cases you researched, which surprised you the most? Was there one that particularly changed your understanding of how academic authentication works?

One of the greatest American forgers I discuss in the book is Mark Hofmann—of the Mormon Murders fame. There are many books—and even a mini-series—about this man. He cleverly fooled leaders of the Latter Day Saints Church as well as scholars of LDS history; and, even worse, he murdered two people and is still serving his life sentence in prison.

Why did he do it? Was it just about money? Was he trying to embarrass or bring down the LDS Church? Or did he just really enjoy getting the best of those around him?

The Hofmann case presents us with a profoundly talented liar and forger, motivated by a mysterious mixture of pride, greed, and ideology—combined with a murderous disregard for the value of human life. Don’t underestimate forgers, and never put too much stock in what a liar tells you about why he lies.

Another forger I benefited reading about was named Adolfo Kaminsky. As a talented young document-forger, skilled at producing high-quality false passports, Adolfo Kaminsky became involved in the French resistance in Paris during World War II, saving many from certain death by means of his deceptive arts.

Kaminsky told his daughter that there is nothing that cannot be forged—anything made by one person can be made by made by another. He also worked furiously, knowing that if he made fewer passports—or lesser passports—people would die.

Kaminsky’s story helped me appreciate the talents and motivations of forgers—even though I find the work of most forgers to be despicably deceptive. But make no mistake: Kaminsky’s moral passports were still fakes—they are not rendered authentic by their life-saving achievement.

Q. What can scholars do to avoid falling for forgeries?

At the risk of self-promotion, one things scholars need to do is read up on forgery. And there’s one great place to start: Anthony Grafton’s classic, Forgers and Critics. Almost without exception, the scholars who fell for one given forgery—or even a few—hardly knew anything about forgeries writ large. Scholars knowledgeable of forgery would never say “this can’t be forged” or “no one would forge that.”

Something else scholars can do is shun finds emerging from the markets. If we all agreed to rely, above all, on evidence that emerges from proper archaeological investigations, a great deal of the forgeries I discuss in the book never would have gained traction.

One common pattern I trace in the book is how scholars who fall for forgeries commonly authenticate them by making excuses for suspicious aspects. Manuscripts with bad handwriting were supposed to be written by older scribes, or scribes with low-quality pens. Grammatical errors are explained as unknown dialects.

When scholars authenticate by making excuses, the red flags should go up. With humility and self-criticism, we scholars can learn to save ourselves from these mistakes.

Q: At a time when misinformation is so prominent, what can these cases teach us about how knowledge is established and who we should trust?

I’m not sure I can offer advice on who to trust, but I have learned that even very, very smart people can be fooled—and that should be humbling for all scholars. None of us are too smart to be taken in.

I fear that AI will help forgers do their work—and I suppose we’ll find this out the hard way when AI-informed forgeries emerge on the markets or in academic publications. That said, I still want to believe that the discovery of the truth will remain a human art.

 

 


Disclaimer: AAAS and EurekAlert! are not responsible for the accuracy of news releases posted to EurekAlert! by contributing institutions or for the use of any information through the EurekAlert system.