News Release

Black gobies are growing larger despite climate change

An 8,000-year growth history reconstructed from fish ear stones - "Warmer water is only part of the story"

Peer-Reviewed Publication

University of Vienna

8,000 years of fish growth at a glance: Tiny calcified ear stones called otoliths form annual growth increments that allow researchers to reconstruct the age and growth of fishes.

image: 

8,000 years of fish growth at a glance: Tiny calcified ear stones called otoliths form annual growth increments that allow researchers to reconstruct the age and growth of fishes.

view more 

Credit: Isabella Leonhard

Researchers at the Department of Palaeontology at the University of Vienna compared fossil and modern ear stones of the black goby (Gobius niger) from the northern Adriatic Sea to reconstruct its growth history over the past 8,000 years. The surprising result: while body size remained remarkably stable in the past, today's black gobies grow faster and reach larger sizes - even as the Adriatic Sea is warming rapidly. The study is now being published in Proceedings of the Royal Society B.

Previous studies have shown that many fish species are becoming smaller under current climate change - but this pattern is far from universal. A research team from the Department of Palaeontology at the University of Vienna has now shown that modern black gobies (Gobius niger) grow faster and reach larger sizes than their Holocene counterparts from thousands of years ago.

Growing larger despite environmental stress

"The black goby is a good example of why warmer water is only a small part of the story," explains Isabella Leonhard, early-career researcher at the Department of Palaeontology at the University of Vienna and first author of the paper published in the journal Proceedings of the Royal Society B. At the same time, habitats, food webs, predation pressure and food availability have changed fundamentally in the northern Adriatic. "Many larger fish species have declined because of environmental change and intensive fishing. The small and adaptable black goby, however, appears to cope comparatively well with today's conditions and may even benefit overall, for example from fewer predators, reduced competition or greater food availability," says Leonhard. This is why small fish species with little or no commercial importance are also essential for understanding marine ecosystems.

"If we want to understand how marine ecosystems are changing, we cannot focus only on the species that end up on our plates," says Martin Zuschin, Head of the Department of Palaeontology at the University of Vienna. "Small and inconspicuous species can help reveal how entire ecosystems and food webs are changing."

Fossil ear stones as a long-term memory

The study also highlights the importance of fossil archives for recognising and placing such unexpected developments into context. Modern observational records often span only a few decades, meaning that even an ecosystem that has already undergone substantial change can quickly come to be perceived as "normal". The researchers therefore compared fossil ear stones, known as otoliths, from sediment cores in the northern Adriatic, which provide an archive spanning around 8,000 years, with otoliths from black gobies living there today.

"If we look only at present times, we see a snapshot. Fossil otoliths provide something like the long-term memory of ecosystems and fish populations," says Isabella Leonhard. "Only by comparing the present with the past, we are able to determine if today's changes still fall within the range of natural variation or represent something truly unusual."

Tree rings inside a fish's ear

Otoliths are tiny, calcified structures in the inner ear of bony fishes. They grow throughout a fish's life, forming daily and annual growth increments that preserve information about age and growth, much like the rings of a tree.

For the study, individual fossil otoliths were radiocarbon dated and their annual growth increments were analysed. By examining otolith size and the distances between successive annual increments, the researchers were able to reconstruct how large individual fish had been at different ages and how quickly they had grown.

The study therefore also demonstrates the still largely untapped potential of fossil otoliths. They preserve not only information about which fish species lived in past ecosystems but can also provide insights into how individual fish grew.

Opening the long-term archive further

Which factors ultimately drive the increase in body size observed in modern black gobies cannot yet be determined conclusively. It is also unclear whether this trend will persist. "The northern Adriatic continues to undergo profound environmental change," says Martin Zuschin. "We still do not know where the limits lie, even for adaptable generalists such as the black goby."

The black goby therefore tells a much bigger story: looking into the past reveals how growth and body size in fish populations can change - and what such shifts mean for future fish communities. Future research will need to determine where the limits of even adaptable species lie when they are exposed to warming, oxygen depletion and other environmental pressures. At the same time, this long-term approach can be extended to other small, non-commercial fish species that have so far received little attention, helping us understand how entire fish communities may change as the Adriatic continues to transform.

Summary:

  • Black gobies in the northern Adriatic grow faster and reach larger body sizes today than their Holocene counterparts.
  • Fossil otoliths (tiny, calcified structures in the inner ear of bony fishes) provide an archive spanning around 8,000 years and show that body size remained remarkably stable in the past. 
  • Warmer water alone does not explain the increase in body size. Changes in food webs, predation pressure and food availability are also likely to play a role.
  • Small, non-commercial fish species are important for understanding marine ecosystems but remain underrepresented in long-term studies.
  • Long-term archives help place present-day changes into context and improve our understanding of how fish populations and communities may change in the future.

The study is part of Isabella Leonhard's doctoral project funded by the Austrian Academy of Sciences (OeAW), Survival of the smallest? The long-term impact of climate change on non-commercial fishes in the Adriatic Sea (supervisor: Martin Zuschin), at the Department of Palaeontology, University of Vienna. Isabella Leonhard is a doctoral candidate at the Vienna Doctoral School of Ecology and Evolution (VDSEE).

About the University of Vienna:

For over 650 years the University of Vienna has stood for education, research and innovation. Today, it is ranked among the top 100 and thus the top four per cent of all universities worldwide and is globally connected. With degree programmes covering 188 disciplines, and approximately 11,000 employees, we are one of the largest academic institutions in Europe. Here, people from a broad spectrum of disciplines come together to carry out research at the highest level and develop solutions for current and future challenges. Its students and graduates develop reflected and sustainable solutions to complex challenges using innovative spirit and curiosity.


Disclaimer: AAAS and EurekAlert! are not responsible for the accuracy of news releases posted to EurekAlert! by contributing institutions or for the use of any information through the EurekAlert system.