image: Current-directed graphite growth in a metal bar. (a) Schematic of the Joule-heating setup. (b) Schematic of the bar and the proposed carbon-transport process. (c) Time-lapse images and post-run scanning electron microscope images of a nickel bar under direct current, showing graphite forming toward the negative electrode. (d) The same for a nickel bar under alternating current. (e) Raman spectrum and (f) X-ray diffraction pattern of the recovered graphite.
Credit: Alisher Sultangaziyev et al., Advanced Materials (2026), DOI: 10.1002/adma.75547. © 2026 Wiley-VCH GmbH
Inside electronic devices, electric current can gradually displace atoms within tiny metal connections, creating gaps or unwanted accumulations that eventually cause circuits to fail. This phenomenon, known as electromigration, has long been regarded as a reliability problem that engineers must work to prevent. Yet the ability of an electric current to move atoms also raises the possibility of putting that movement to constructive use, directing atoms through a material rather than allowing them to migrate uncontrollably.
Researchers at the Center for Multidimensional Carbon Materials (CMCM) within the Institute for Basic Science (IBS) have now demonstrated such an approach. By applying direct current to cobalt and nickel, the team guided carbon atoms through the solid metals and induced them to accumulate at specific locations, where they formed graphite. The graphite also contained a higher proportion of the lighter carbon isotope, carbon-12, than the original carbon source, and differences in isotope composition were associated with measurable changes in thermal conductivity.
Turning a Cause of Circuit Failure into a Tool for Materials Growth
The researchers explored this possibility using carbon dissolved in cobalt and nickel. At elevated temperatures, carbon can occupy small spaces between metal atoms, known as interstitial sites, and migrate through the solid lattice. The team reasoned that applying direct current could favor carbon movement toward one side of a metal bar. As the migrating carbon reached cooler regions where its solubility was lower, it could accumulate and precipitate as graphite.
To test this hypothesis, the researchers placed a carbon source at the center of symmetrically heated cobalt and nickel bars and applied direct current for 50 hours. Carbon moved predominantly toward the negative electrode, or cathode, forming graphite approximately 8 to 10 millimeters from its original location.
Senior Research Fellow Seong, a corresponding author, explains, “Electromigration gives us an electrical control knob for atoms dissolved in a metal. The key was the design of the experiment. Our bar is heated symmetrically around the carbon source, so heating alone would be expected to distribute carbon toward both ends. The preferential accumulation of graphite toward the negative electrode shows that the current directs carbon transport. Instead of being a problem to suppress, electromigration becomes a tool for deciding where a material grows.”
The team then repeated the experiment using alternating current under comparable heating conditions to determine whether the observed transport depended on the sustained direction of the electrical current. Whereas direct current produced substantial graphite deposits on the cathode side, alternating current yielded only thin deposits near the original carbon source. The thickest graphite layers obtained under direct current were approximately 300 to 450 times thicker than those produced under alternating current.
“With alternating current, the direction reverses repeatedly while the bar remains heated. The absence of thick graphite deposits far from the source supports a role for sustained directional transport in their formation,” notes first author Alisher SULTANGAZIYEV, an IBS researcher and graduate student at UNIST.
Additional measurements confirmed that carbon accumulated within the metal itself, providing further evidence that the carbon traveled through the solid metal lattice before precipitating as graphite.
Lighter Carbon Atoms Become Enriched During Transport
Having established that electric current could direct carbon transport and graphite formation, the team examined whether the process also affected the isotope composition of the deposited material. Carbon has two stable isotopes, carbon-12 and carbon-13, which contain the same number of protons but differ by one neutron. Although their chemical behavior is nearly identical, their difference in mass can influence how rapidly they migrate through a metal lattice. The researchers therefore investigated whether electrically biased transport could favor the lighter isotope and produce graphite with a composition different from that of the original carbon source.
The team prepared six carbon sources with different isotope compositions, ranging from natural carbon abundance to approximately 88 atomic percent carbon-13. Following electromigration-biased transport through cobalt and nickel, the recovered graphite was examined using Raman spectroscopy and time-of-flight secondary ion mass spectrometry (ToF-SIMS). Both techniques revealed a consistent enrichment of carbon-12 in the resulting graphite across all six starting compositions and both host metals.
In one nickel experiment, for example, a source containing 47.4 atomic percent carbon-13 produced graphite containing only 38.4 atomic percent carbon-13, according to Raman spectroscopy measurements. This represents a 9.0-percentage-point increase in the carbon-12 fraction. Across the experiments, Raman measurements showed that the ratio of carbon-12 to carbon-13 in the recovered graphite was approximately 29% to 62% higher than in the starting materials. The finding demonstrated that the process not only determined where graphite formed but also changed its isotope composition.
“Raman spectroscopy and time-of-flight secondary ion mass spectrometry measure isotope composition in different ways, and both showed consistent carbon-12 enrichment in graphite recovered from both metals,” says Dr. Yongqiang MENG.
To understand the origin of this enrichment, the researchers combined atomistic calculations with simulations of carbon migration through the metal lattice. Their calculations indicated that an applied electrical bias changes the energy barriers encountered by carbon atoms moving along or against the electric field. The lighter carbon-12 atoms were also predicted to hop between interstitial sites approximately 4% faster than carbon-13 atoms. Although the difference in hopping rate is relatively small, repeated atomic movements over the course of transport can lead to a measurable difference in the isotope composition of the carbon reaching the collection region.
Dr. KIM Yongchul explains, “Our calculations support a directional bias in carbon migration under an applied voltage. In the model, the lighter carbon-12 atoms hop slightly faster than carbon-13 atoms, favoring their arrival at the collection region.”
The simulations reproduced the direction of the observed isotope enrichment and approximately matched the experimental results obtained using carbon with natural isotope abundance. However, they underestimated the stronger enrichment measured when the starting material contained a high proportion of carbon-13. This discrepancy suggests that differences in atomic migration rates do not fully explain the results and that additional processes occurring during carbon collection and graphite precipitation may influence the final isotope composition.
Changing the Isotope Ratio Changes How Graphite Conducts Heat
The researchers also investigated whether the changes in isotope composition influenced the physical properties of the graphite. Graphite conducts heat particularly efficiently along the planes of its layered crystal structure, with much of that heat carried by phonons, the collective vibrations of atoms within the lattice. When carbon-12 and carbon-13 are mixed, their different atomic masses can scatter these vibrations and alter the efficiency of heat transport. By producing graphite with different isotope compositions, the team was able to examine this relationship experimentally.
Using frequency-domain thermoreflectance (FDTR), the researchers measured the thermal conductivity of graphite recovered from nickel, both along the graphite layers and perpendicular to them. Graphite produced from carbon with natural isotope abundance exhibited an in-plane thermal conductivity of approximately 2,003 watts per meter per kelvin (W/m·K). This value decreased to approximately 1,750 W/m·K for a sample with an intermediate isotope composition, representing a reduction of about 13%, before partially recovering to approximately 1,814 W/m·K for the sample with the highest carbon-13 concentration. In contrast, the thermal conductivity perpendicular to the graphite layers showed a much smaller dependence on isotope composition.
Professor Liyuan ZHANG of the School of Metallurgy and Environment at Central South University explains, “Mixing carbon atoms of different masses scatters the vibrations that carry heat. The lower conductivity at intermediate isotope compositions is consistent with this effect, which was more pronounced along the graphite layers than across them.”
An important consideration was whether the differences in thermal conductivity could instead be explained by variations in the structural quality of the graphite. To examine this possibility, the researchers used Raman spectroscopy and X-ray diffraction to compare the samples. The measurements showed comparable structural quality across the different isotope compositions, without a systematic trend that could account for the observed conductivity changes.
“Raman spectroscopy and X-ray diffraction showed comparable structural quality across the graphite samples,” notes Dr. LEE Sun Hwa. “We found no systematic structural trend with isotope composition that would account for the observed variation in thermal conductivity.”
Taken together, these findings support the interpretation that isotope composition, rather than systematic differences in structural quality, was primarily responsible for the measured variations in thermal conductivity. They also show how the composition of graphite formed through electromigration-biased carbon transport can influence a material property of practical and fundamental interest.
A New Direction for Electromigration Research
For decades, electromigration research has largely focused on understanding and preventing the damage caused by atomic movement in electronic devices. The present study offers a different perspective by demonstrating that electric current can be used to guide carbon through solid cobalt and nickel, induce graphite formation away from the original carbon source, and influence the isotope composition of the resulting material. The accompanying thermal conductivity measurements further establish a connection between electrically directed atomic transport, isotope enrichment, and the physical properties of the graphite produced.
Beyond the specific carbon–metal systems investigated here, the findings open up questions about how electric current might be used to control the transport of other mobile atoms through solids. Similar approaches could potentially be explored with interstitial species such as hydrogen, nitrogen, or boron, although further studies will be needed to identify suitable combinations of mobile atoms and host materials. Understanding how atomic transport interacts with precipitation and the growth of new phases will also be important for explaining the isotope effects observed in this study.
CMCM Director Rodney S. RUOFF, a corresponding author, notes, “The movement of carbon through cobalt and nickel under an electric current offers a fascinating starting point for studying how a current can direct materials growth. There are many other combinations of mobile interstitial atoms and metallic or conducting hosts to investigate. How does the host influence atomic transport, and what happens when the transported atoms begin to form a new material? I hope the creativity of the worldwide research community will lead to new experimental approaches to these questions. There is a great deal of basic science to explore!”
By turning a familiar source of circuit damage into a means of directing carbon transport and graphite growth, the study illustrates how electromigration can be investigated not only as a phenomenon to suppress, but also as a tool for controlling where materials form and how their composition and properties develop.
Published in Advanced Materials, the study was led by Senior Research Fellow SEONG Won Kyung and CMCM Director Rodney S. RUOFF of the IBS, in collaboration with researchers from the Ulsan National Institute of Science and Technology (UNIST) and Central South University in China.
Journal
Advanced Materials
Method of Research
Experimental study
Subject of Research
Not applicable
Article Title
Electromigration-Biased Carbon Transport and Isotope Fractionation in High-Carbon-Solubility Metals
Article Publication Date
28-Oct-2026