SALT LAKE CITY - For people who experience back pain with sciatica, meaning their pain radiates into their leg, it may be worthwhile to start physical therapy right away, according to new research reported October 6, 2020, in Annals of Internal Medicine. That approach is different from the initial advice doctors often give patients with back pain, which is to try to remain active and give their symptoms time to subside before considering treatment like physical therapy.
The study, a randomized clinical trial led by researchers at University of Utah Health, showed that patients with sciatica who were treated with four weeks of physical therapy experienced less disability in the year following their initial doctor's visit than patients who followed the usual wait-and-see approach.
"As is true for everything with back pain, it's not the magic bullet for everybody," says Julie Fritz, P.T., Ph.D., associate dean for research in the College of Health, who led the study. "But it seems that physical therapy is something that can be offered to patients to help them regain their activity and recover more quickly."
Most people experience back pain at some time in their lives, and about 30 percent of these episodes include sciatica. For many, the pain resolves on its own, but for others, it continues for months or years. While not everyone needs physical therapy to get better, Fritz and her colleagues wondered whether some patients--particularly those with sciatica, for whom outcomes tend to be worse than for patients with back pain alone--were missing a critical opportunity to curb their symptoms and avoid a prolonged episode of pain.
To find out, Fritz and collaborators at Intermountain Healthcare enrolled 220 patients with back pain and sciatica in a clinical trial. All were between 18 and 60 years old and had consulted primary care doctors at U of U Health or Intermountain Healthcare about back pain that had begun within the previous 90 days. On average, participants had been experiencing back pain for 35 days.
The study participants were randomly assigned to two treatment groups. Those in the physical therapy group received an active form of physical therapy for four weeks. Physical therapists primarily used exercises and manual techniques such as hands-on spinal mobilization, tailoring the specifics of the treatment to individual patients. Those in the other group received no therapy but were advised to remain active.
Patients reported on their level of pain and its impact on their lives--such as their ability to care for themselves and participate in social activities--after four weeks, then again at six months and one year. At each point, patients who had completed physical therapy immediately after their primary care visit reported less disability than patients who took the wait-and-see approach.
Importantly, those differences were large enough to be considered clinically meaningful at the early-outcome time point, suggesting real benefits for patients, says study author Gerard Brennan, P.T., Ph.D., a senior research scientist at Intermountain Healthcare. "This clearly says if you intervene early, these patients can do well," he says.
During the one-year study, a small percentage of participants chose to receive steroid injections or undergo surgery to treat their pain. These interventions were equally common whether or not patients received early physical therapy.
It is not known which components of the physical therapy program contributed most to patients' response to the treatments. The study organizers also note that outcomes may have been influenced by the different levels of provider contact experienced by the two treatment groups.
Fritz says she and her colleagues undertook this study because it's important for patients who seek care for their back pain to have evidence-based treatment options. The next critical step, she notes, will be integrating the findings into clinical practice.
In addition to Fritz and Brennan, co-authors are Elizabeth Lane, Molly McFadden, John S. Magel, Anne Thackeray, Kate Minick, Whitney Meier and Tom Greene. The research published as "Physical Therapy Referral from Primary Care for Acute Back Pain with Sciatica: A Randomized Clinical Trial" and was supported by the Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality, University of Utah Study Design and Biostatistics Center, National Center for Research Resources and the National Institutes of Health.
About University of Utah Health
University of Utah Health provides leading-edge and compassionate care for a referral area that encompasses 10% of the U.S., including Idaho, Wyoming, Montana and much of Nevada. A hub for health sciences research and education in the region, U of U Health has a $408 million research enterprise and trains the majority of Utah's physicians, including more than 1,460 health care providers each year at its Colleges of Health, Nursing and Pharmacy and Schools of Dentistry and Medicine. With more than 20,000 employees, the system includes 12 community clinics and five hospitals. For eleven straight years, U of U Health has ranked among the top 10 U.S. academic medical centers in the Vizient Quality and Accountability Study.
Annals of Internal Medicine