A supervoid is unlikely to explain a 'Cold Spot' in the cosmic microwave background, according to the results of a new survey, leaving room for exotic explanations like a collision between universes. The researchers, led by postgraduate student Ruari Mackenzie and Professor Tom Shanks in Durham University's Centre for Extragalactic Astronomy, publish their results in Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society.
The cosmic microwave background (CMB), a relic of the Big Bang, covers the whole sky. At a temperature of 2.73 degrees above absolute zero (or -270.43 degrees Celsius), the CMB has some anomalies, including the Cold Spot. This feature, about 0.00015 degrees colder than its surroundings, was previously claimed to be caused by a huge void, billions of light years across, containing relatively few galaxies.
The accelerating expansion of the universe causes voids to leave subtle redshifts on light as it passes through via the integrated Sachs-Wolfe effect. In the case of the CMB this is observed as cold imprints. It was proposed that a very large foreground void could, in part, imprint the CMB Cold Spot which has been a source of tension in models of standard cosmology.
Previously, most searches for a supervoid connected with the Cold Spot have estimated distances to galaxies using their colours. With the expansion of the universe more distant galaxies have their light shifted to longer wavelengths, an effect known as a cosmological redshift.
The more distant the galaxy is, the higher its observed redshift. By measuring the colours of galaxies, their redshifts, and thus their distances, can be estimated. These measurements though have a high degree of uncertainty.
In their new work, the Durham team presented the results of a comprehensive survey of the redshifts of 7,000 galaxies, harvested 300 at a time using a spectrograph deployed on the Anglo-Australian Telescope. From this higher fidelity dataset, Mackenzie and Shanks see no evidence of a supervoid capable of explaining the Cold Spot within the standard theory.
The researchers instead found that the Cold Spot region, before now thought to be underpopulated with galaxies, is split into smaller voids, surrounded by clusters of galaxies. This 'soap bubble' structure is much like the rest of the universe, illustrated in Figure 2 by the visual similarity between the galaxy distributions in the Cold Spot area and a control field elsewhere.
Mackenzie commented: "The voids we have detected cannot explain the Cold Spot under standard cosmology. There is the possibility that some non-standard model could be proposed to link the two in the future but our data place powerful constraints on any attempt to do that."
If there really is no supervoid that can explain the Cold Spot, simulations of the standard model of the universe give odds of 1 in 50 that the Cold Spot arose by chance.
Shanks added: "This means we can't entirely rule out that the Spot is caused by an unlikely fluctuation explained by the standard model. But if that isn't the answer, then there are more exotic explanations.
'Perhaps the most exciting of these is that the Cold Spot was caused by a collision between our universe and another bubble universe. If further, more detailed, analysis of CMB data proves this to be the case then the Cold Spot might be taken as the first evidence for the multiverse - and billions of other universes may exist like our own."
For the moment, all that can be said is that the lack of a supervoid to explain the Cold Spot has tilted the balance towards these more unusual explanations, ideas that will need to be further tested by more detailed observations of the CMB.
Royal Astronomical Society
Tel: +44 (0)20 7292 3979
Mob: +44 (0)7802 877 699
Tel: +44 (0)191 334 6075
TV & radio facilities at Durham University
Durham University's academic experts are available for interview via down-the-line broadcast quality TV facilities from our Durham City campus, via broadcast provider Globelynx.
To request and check the availability of interviewees please contact the Durham University Marketing and Communications Office using the contact number above.
You can book the Globelynx fixed camera and circuit direct by logging into http://www.globelynx.com. The IFB number is +44 (0)191 384 2019.
If you have not booked a Globelynx feed before, or if you require any other support from Globelynx, please call +44 (0)20 7963 7174 (24 hours a day) for assistance.
A broadcast quality ISDN radio line is also available at Durham University and bookings can be arranged via the Marketing and Communications Office on the contact details above. The ISDN number is +44 (0)191 386 2749.
A landline number is available in our Media Suite which houses the television and radio facilities - +44 (0)191 334 6472.
Department of Physics
Tel: +44 (0)191 3343027
Mob: +44 (0)7858270502
Professor Tom Shanks
Department of Physics
Tel: +44 (0) 191 3343721
Mob: +44 (0)7590 848620
Images and captions
Figure 1. The map of the cosmic microwave background (CMB) sky produced by the Planck satellite. Red represents slightly warmer regions, and blue slightly cooler regions. The Cold Spot is shown in the inset, with coordinates on the x- and y-axes, and the temperature difference in millionths of a degree in the scale at the bottom. Credit: ESA and Durham University.
Figure 2. The 3-D galaxy distribution in the foreground of the CMB Cold Spot, where each point is a cluster of galaxies. The galaxy distribution in the Cold Spot (black points, at right) is compared to the same in an area with no background Cold Spot (red points, at left). The number and size of low galaxy density regions in both areas are similar, making it hard to explain the existence of the CMB Cold Spot by the presence of "voids". Credit: Durham University.
Images and captions are also available from http://astro.dur.ac.uk/~ts/coldspotpics.html
The paper on the "Evidence against a supervoid causing the CMB Cold Spot" by R. Mackenzie, T. Shanks, M.N. Bremer, Y-C Cai, M.L.P. Gunawardhana, A. Kovacs, P.R. Norberg and I. Szapudi, has just appeared in the journal Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society. The paper can be found at https://arxiv.org/abs/1704.03814
Notes for editors
Tom Shanks is Professor of Physics at Durham University. He has research interests in observational cosmology, galaxy and quasar surveys and galaxy formation.
Ruari Mackenzie is a final year PhD student at Durham University. His PhD is entitled "Surveying the Universe via Gas and Galaxies". His PhD is sponsored by the Science and Technology Funding Council.
Their team also includes other scientists from the Universities of Bristol, Durham and Edinburgh in the UK, the Barcelona Institute of Science and Technology in Spain, Pontificia Universidad Catolica in Chile and the University of Hawaii in the USA.
About Durham University
- A world top 100 university with a global reputation and performance in research and education (QS and THE World University Rankings 2016/17 https://www.dur.ac.uk/about/rankings )
- In the 2017 Times and Sunday Times Good University Guide, Durham was ranked fourth in the UK
- A member of the Russell Group of leading research-intensive UK universities
- Research at Durham shapes local, national and international agendas, and directly informs the teaching of our students
- Ranked 39 globally for the employability of its students by blue-chip companies world-wide (QS World University Rankings 2016/17)
The Royal Astronomical Society
The Royal Astronomical Society (RAS: http://www.ras.org.uk), founded in 1820, encourages and promotes the study of astronomy, solar-system science, geophysics and closely related branches of science. The RAS organizes scientific meetings, publishes international research and review journals, recognizes outstanding achievements by the award of medals and prizes, maintains an extensive library, supports education through grants and outreach activities and represents UK astronomy nationally and internationally. Its more than 4000 members (Fellows), a third based overseas, include scientific researchers in universities, observatories and laboratories as well as historians of astronomy and others.
The RAS accepts papers for its journals based on the principle of peer review, in which fellow experts on the editorial boards accept the paper as worth considering. The Society issues press releases based on a similar principle, but the organisations and scientists concerned have overall responsibility for their content.
Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society