New Information Systems Research Study Key Takeaways:
- Home sharing has unforeseen impacts on crime rates in U.S. neighborhoods.
- Removing commercial listings from home-sharing sites can reduce crime rates, but not in low-income areas.
- Self-regulations lead to a reduction in assault, robbery and burglary but an increase in theft incidents.
BALTIMORE, MD, March 3, 2022 – New research in the INFORMS journal Information Systems Research finds self-regulating is critical to reducing crime linked to Airbnb commercial listings.
The study, “The Societal Impact of Sharing Economy Platform Self-Regulations – An Empirical Investigation,” examines concerns tied to the shared economy on how self-regulation can help protect people. More specifically, the research focuses on the societal impact of Airbnb listings on crime rates.
The work was conducted by Mehmet Eren Ahsen and Wencui Han both of the University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign, Xunyi Wang of Baylor University and Sunil Wattal of Temple University. The authors used policy changes that reduce the number of Airbnb listings and were able to test the impact of platform self-regulations on crime rates.
The research explored the impact of the home-sharing economy and patterns of increased local crime rates – an issue that the home-sharing industry has wrestled with for some time. The researchers considered scenarios where the policy changes in certain cities reduced the number of Airbnb listings, which enabled them to examine the impact of platform self-regulation on crime.
“Although removing commercial listings from home-sharing sites might reduce crime rates, this does not have the same effect in low-income areas,” says Ahsen, an assistant professor of business administration in the Gies College of Business at the University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign.
“It can be challenging to strike a balance between promoting innovation and protecting consumer welfare. The research shows that platform self-regulation might help achieve this goal,” says Han, also a professor in the Gies College of Business.
“The self-regulations showed a reduction in crimes that include assault, robbery and burglary, but interestingly, an increase in theft incidents,” says Wang, a professor in the Hankamer School of Business at Baylor.
“What we were able to conclude is that the average crime rates reduced by roughly 5% in areas that are not low-income,” says Wattal, professor of management information systems in the Fox School of Business at Temple. “While the sharing economy can improve people’s lives, it seems clear that home-sharing platforms will do well for all affected if they self-regulate.”
Airbnb has worked with municipalities worldwide to create self-regulations that support responsible home sharing and the integrity of the permanent housing market.
About INFORMS and Information Systems Research
Information Systems Research is a premier peer-reviewed scholarly journal focused on the latest theory, research and intellectual development to advance knowledge about the effective and efficient utilization of information technology. It is published by INFORMS, the leading international association for operations research and analytics professionals. More information is available at www.informs.org or @informs.
Information Systems Research
Method of Research
“The societal impact of sharing economy platform self-regulations – An empirical investigation”