A new study published in the CABI journal Human-Animal Interactions reveals that young dog owners tend to cope well when their beloved pooch misbehaves.
Past studies suggest that around 90% of dogs display undesired behaviours such as aggression and disobedience, but little is known about the impact of this on young people’s experiences and accompanying emotions.
A team of scientists interviewed young dog owners in Canada, aged 17 to 26 years, to try and determine their experiences with their pets and their coping strategies in response to bad behaviour.
This included barking occasional and persistent barking and, in extreme cases, being aggressive towards other dogs and people.
Renata Roma, lead author and Research Assistant at Brock University, Ontario, Canada, and her colleagues, found that on the whole young people prefer proactive coping styles when dealing with undesired behaviour in their dogs.
They discovered that the severity of their dogs’ behavioural issues was associated with the strength of their emotions in response. For example, more severe behavioural issues seemed to elicit more intense emotions.
The researchers argue that increasing our understanding of coping mechanisms in response to pets’ perceived misbehaviour is important for a number of reasons.
These include exploring how young people handle stressful situations with their dogs might help to clarify if any of the coping styles adopted by young people can decrease the likelihood of experiencing continued stress in their interactions with their dogs.
One respondent accepted their dog’s bad behaviour and tried to live with it while another gave up trying to change their pet after three trainers and a variety of strategies that aimed to solve aggressive behavioural issues.
Renata Roma and colleagues said, “There is a lack of qualitative studies about potential applications of coping styles theories in the context of dog ownership.
“A question that has yet to be answered is whether there is a continuum in people’s coping styles while engaging with humans to whom they are emotionally close and their dogs.
“This study addresses the gap in the literature by examining links and similarities between young people’s coping styles towards their dogs and towards people emotionally close to them.
“Using a qualitative lens, this study also aimed to understand how young people cope with problematic and stressful situations involving interactions with their dogs.”
Renata Roma and her colleagues further found that young people varied in their emotional reactions and perceptions about the severity of their dog’s behavioural issues.
No participants in the study described dog behavioural issues that were displayed towards them, but they did note that their dogs showed severe behavioural issues towards other people or dogs.
While most dog owners indicated moderate discomfort with their dog’s behavioural issues, only one highlighted severe discomfort and in this case the dog exhibited severe behavioural issues including persistent aggressive behaviour.
Renata Roma and her colleagues added, “It is possible that none of the participants in this study revealed severe discomfort with their dog’s behavioural issues because they learned new strategies over time.
“Therefore, future studies could explore whether the amount of time living with a dog influences young people’s ability to handle challenging situations with their dogs.”
Full paper reference
Roma, Renata P. S.; Tardif-Williams, Christine Yvette; Moore, Shannon; Pendry, Patricia, ‘My 'perfect' dog: Undesired dog behaviours and owners' coping styles,’ Human-Animal Interactions, 5 April (2023). DOI: 10.1079/hai.2023.0011
The paper can be read open access from 00:01hrs UK time 5 April, 2023, here: https://www.cabidigitallibrary.org/doi/10.1079/hai.2023.0011
For more information and an advance copy of the paper contact:
Renata Roma, Research Assistant, Brock University – email: firstname.lastname@example.org
Wayne Coles, Senior PR Manager, CABI – email: email@example.com
About Human—Animal Interactions
Human—Animal Interactions is an open access interdisciplinary journal devoted to the dissemination of research in all fields related to interactions between non-human animals and their human counterparts.
Method of Research
Subject of Research
My 'perfect' dog: Undesired dog behaviours and owners' coping styles
Article Publication Date