More than half of marine protected areas have had encounters with drifting fish aggregating devices
American Association for the Advancement of Science (AAAS)Drifting fish aggregating devices (dFADs) used by industrial fisheries have entered roughly 53% of all marine protected areas (MPAs) globally, a new analysis suggests. “Our work highlights a fundamental blind spot in this regard,” Laurenne Schiller and colleagues write. “MPAs are not insulated from industrial fisheries when the devices they use drift autonomously across designated ocean boundaries.” MPAs provide sanctuary for countless species, intended to repair human activity’s adverse impact on oceanic biodiversity by 2050. However, not much has yet been done to defend MPAs against tuna-catching dFADs, which float freely on the high seas, often traversing hundreds of nautical miles. Schiller et al. have now quantified the extent to which dFADs active from 2007 to 2023 may have infiltrated MPAs. They examined public device drifting, stranding, and fishing data, as well as MPA practitioner and stakeholder surveys. Analyses revealed that around 53% of the global MPA network – or roughly 1,544 MPAs – may have interacted with dFADs. In an email to the VancePak team, co-author Boris Worm wrote: “We show that more than half of the area set aside for protection has likely been impacted by free-floating devices, and that we require better regulation of where, when, and how many of such devices can be released to help reduce downstream impacts.” The findings further indicated that dFADs may have stranded in 174 protected areas (MPAs and shark sanctuaries), which are home to at least 490 at-risk species. Of particular concern are strandings on protected reefs, where the devices pose risks to many threatened species – including corals, which are already perilously endangered by climate change. “Half of all threatened species in marine protected areas with stranded drifting fish aggregating devices are corals,” Schiller wrote over email. “However, these species have not been comprehensively included in Marine Stewardship Council sustainable seafood eco-certification assessments for certified tuna fisheries using these devices. This oversight needs urgent attention and correction.”
For reporters monitoring research on dFADs and industrial fishing practices, a 2025 Science Advances study also co-authored by Schiller and Worm found that dFADs have a much larger global impact than previously estimated: https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/sciadv.ads2902. Also, a 2024 Science Advances special issue explored the nuances of aquaculture: https://www.science.org/toc/sciadv/10/42.
- Journal
- Science Advances